Person

Buford Homer Shupe

One of four people charged in the April 1, 1965 robbery of the Boyce branch of the Bank of Clarke County. The Winchester Evening Star reported he pleaded guilty on May 10, 1965 and was sentenced by Judge Elliott D. Marshall on July 12, 1965 to 15 years in the state penitentiary. The held reports do not establish how much time he actually served.

What the sources support

The Star reported that Kenneth Lloyd Presgraves, Buford Homer Shupe and James Clarence Powell pleaded guilty on May 10, 1965, and that Mary Matilda Shupe initially pleaded innocent.

✓ Supported by a source
See the source and its limits
✓ Supported by a sourceAn account exists

The Star reported that Kenneth Lloyd Presgraves, Buford Homer Shupe and James Clarence Powell pleaded guilty on May 10, 1965, and that Mary Matilda Shupe initially pleaded innocent.

What the source supports

The reported pleas of all four defendants as of May 10, 1965.

Uncertainty

Reported pleas; original court orders have not been read for this claim.

Source

Reporting

Evidence role: supports. The May 11 report of the three guilty pleas and Mary Shupe's initial plea.

“3 Plead Guilty in Bank Case,” Winchester Evening Star, May 11, 1965, page 1

Winchester Evening Star · 1965-05-11 (publication)

Locator: Page 1, “3 Plead Guilty in Bank Case”

Checked: Catalog index only. Original image not independently inspected.

Open source

Source family: winchester-evening-star-1965-boyce-robbery. Multiple passages from one source are not independent witnesses.

AI-assisted integration (Claude Sonnet 5) from a researched narrative and a claim-to-source map; the newspaper pages were not independently re-read for this integration. · 2026-09-29. How this project checks its sources

The Star reported that on July 12, 1965, Judge Elliott D. Marshall sentenced Presgraves to 20 years, Shupe to 15 years and Powell to 10 years in the state penitentiary; the July 13 report was repeated in the August 11 coverage.

✓ Supported by a source
See the source and its limits
✓ Supported by a sourceAn account exists

The Star reported that on July 12, 1965, Judge Elliott D. Marshall sentenced Presgraves to 20 years, Shupe to 15 years and Powell to 10 years in the state penitentiary; the July 13 report was repeated in the August 11 coverage.

What the source supports

The three men's reported sentences and the sentencing date.

Uncertainty

These are the reported sentences; the held newspaper accounts do not establish how much time each man actually served, and no penitentiary or parole record has been read.

Source

Reporting

Evidence role: supports. The July 13 sentencing report.

“3 Get Penitentiary Terms In Clarke Bank Robbery,” Winchester Evening Star, July 13, 1965, page 1

Winchester Evening Star · 1965-07-13 (publication)

Locator: Page 1, “3 Get Penitentiary Terms In Clarke Bank Robbery”

Checked: Catalog index only. Original image not independently inspected.

Open source

Source family: winchester-evening-star-1965-boyce-robbery. Multiple passages from one source are not independent witnesses.

Reporting

Evidence role: supports. The August 11 report, which repeats the three sentences.

“Mrs. Shupe Changes Plea In Bank Case,” Winchester Evening Star, August 11, 1965, page 1

Winchester Evening Star · 1965-08-11 (publication)

Locator: Page 1, “Mrs. Shupe Changes Plea In Bank Case”

Checked: Catalog index only. Original image not independently inspected.

Open source

Source family: winchester-evening-star-1965-boyce-robbery. Multiple passages from one source are not independent witnesses.

AI-assisted integration (Claude Sonnet 5) from a researched narrative and a claim-to-source map; the newspaper pages were not independently re-read for this integration. · 2026-09-29. How this project checks its sources

Life dates that aren't known aren't guessed at here.

Know who this was, or something the records here miss? Help fill a gap. It stays private until it is reviewed.

Keep exploring

Related stories

Civic life & gathering✓ Supported

A pencil at Lanham's: the Boyce bank robbery of 1965

On April 1, 1965, two armed men robbed the Boyce branch of the Bank of Clarke County. A customer's pencil-written license number, relayed to state police, led a trooper to stop the getaway car within the half hour. The account that follows is built entirely from the Winchester Evening Star's contemporary reporting and one conflicting reprint on the money recovered; a fourth defendant's final result is not established in the reports reviewed for this account.

What the evidence says Eight Winchester Evening Star issues from April through September 1965, plus one modern reprint of a ninth, conflicting April 8, 1965 account. None of the nine items was read directly by the editors who wrote this account.

  • 4 min read
  • 9 sources

Search

Searches the released collection only.