Place

Richmond’s wartime prisons

The Confederate prisons in Richmond, Virginia, which a Clarke Courier item of 1886 reached back to. Prisoners of war were held first in converted tobacco warehouses at Rocketts under an officer the Richmond Dispatch called Capt. Gibbs; early in March 1862 they were moved into the Libby and Sons building, which became Libby Prison under Lieutenant Thomas P. Turner. Castle Thunder, a separate Richmond prison often confused with Libby, was commanded by Captain George W. Alexander. This entity exists because the anecdote turns on which prison and which officer, and those are different questions.

No coordinates or district boundaries have been assigned, so this place is not placed on a map.

What the sources support

The old man is given as answering: “I am, sir, Captain Jack Warner, and you are Quartermaster Murphy, and you escaped from the prison at Libby while I was commissary of that institution,” and the stranger as replying that he had indeed boarded with him and given him the slip.

✓ Supported by a source
See the source and its limits
✓ Supported by a sourceAn account exists

The old man is given as answering: “I am, sir, Captain Jack Warner, and you are Quartermaster Murphy, and you escaped from the prison at Libby while I was commissary of that institution,” and the stranger as replying that he had indeed boarded with him and given him the slip.

What the source supports

The identification the item makes, as the item makes it.

Uncertainty

This is what the Courier printed, not an identification the records confirm. No Captain Jack Warner has been located among Libby’s commissaries in the published accounts read for this page, and Quartermaster Murphy has not been checked at all. Both remain open. The item carries no credit line, and the Courier ran uncredited filler routinely, so the page does not establish that the meeting happened in Berryville, in Clarke County, or at all. What is established is what the paper printed.

Source

Reporting

Evidence role: supports. The naming, quoted in full.

Clarke Courier (Berryville, Va.), March 25, 1886, page 1: "An Old Acquaintance"

Clarke Courier · 1886-03-25 (publication)

Locator: Page 1, column 4, "An Old Acquaintance", the naming

Relevant passage
I am, sir, Captain Jack Warner, and you are Quartermaster Murphy, and you escaped from the prison at Libby while I was commissary of that institution.

Checked: Original inspected. A digital reproduction was inspected; no original has been handled.

Open source

Source family: clarke-courier-1886-old-acquaintance. Multiple passages from one source are not independent witnesses.

Reporting

Evidence role: supports. The stranger’s reply.

Clarke Courier (Berryville, Va.), March 25, 1886, page 1: "An Old Acquaintance"

Clarke Courier · 1886-03-25 (publication)

Locator: Page 1, column 4, "An Old Acquaintance", the recognition

Relevant passage
Are you, indeed, the old commissary? Well, you are right. I did board with you; and I gave you the slip, too.

Checked: Original inspected. A digital reproduction was inspected; no original has been handled.

Open source

Source family: clarke-courier-1886-old-acquaintance. Multiple passages from one source are not independent witnesses.

AI-assisted source check (Claude Opus 5) · 2026-09-24. How this project checks its sources

The Courier explained that Murphy belonged to a New York regiment and was captured and sent to Libby, and that prisoners who were practitioners of medicine were allowed to attend the sick in the prison hospital, with the freedom of the grounds, to go and come at will.

✓ Supported by a source
See the source and its limits
✓ Supported by a sourceAn account exists

The Courier explained that Murphy belonged to a New York regiment and was captured and sent to Libby, and that prisoners who were practitioners of medicine were allowed to attend the sick in the prison hospital, with the freedom of the grounds, to go and come at will.

What the source supports

The liberty the item says made the escape possible.

Uncertainty

The item’s own explanation. No prison regulation, order or roster was consulted for this page. The item carries no credit line, and the Courier ran uncredited filler routinely, so the page does not establish that the meeting happened in Berryville, in Clarke County, or at all. What is established is what the paper printed.

Source

Reporting

Evidence role: supports. The liberty allowed the prisoner doctors.

Clarke Courier (Berryville, Va.), March 25, 1886, page 1: "An Old Acquaintance"

Clarke Courier · 1886-03-25 (publication)

Locator: Page 1, column 4, "An Old Acquaintance", the doctors’ liberty

Relevant passage
Prisoners who were practitioners of medicine were allowed to attend the sick in the prison hospital, with the freedom of the grounds, to go and come at will.

Checked: Original inspected. A digital reproduction was inspected; no original has been handled.

Open source

Source family: clarke-courier-1886-old-acquaintance. Multiple passages from one source are not independent witnesses.

AI-assisted source check (Claude Opus 5) · 2026-09-24. How this project checks its sources

The item says a green sentry would not let the doctors pass and was sharply reprimanded by Captain Gibbs, who told him that men wearing red ribbons on their coat lapel should pass unmolested, and that Murphy overheard it, tore a strip of red flannel from inside his vest, pinned it to his coat, got past the guard and reached the Union lines in safety.

✓ Supported by a source
See the source and its limits
✓ Supported by a sourceAn account exists

The item says a green sentry would not let the doctors pass and was sharply reprimanded by Captain Gibbs, who told him that men wearing red ribbons on their coat lapel should pass unmolested, and that Murphy overheard it, tore a strip of red flannel from inside his vest, pinned it to his coat, got past the guard and reached the Union lines in safety.

What the source supports

The escape as the Courier described it.

Uncertainty

The Courier’s account of an escape, printed at least twenty years after it is said to have happened, with no date and no named unit beyond “a New York regiment.” Whether the officer it calls Captain Gibbs was at Libby at all is not established by anything read for this page. The item carries no credit line, and the Courier ran uncredited filler routinely, so the page does not establish that the meeting happened in Berryville, in Clarke County, or at all. What is established is what the paper printed.

Source

Reporting

Evidence role: supports. The reprimand and the red ribbons.

Clarke Courier (Berryville, Va.), March 25, 1886, page 1: "An Old Acquaintance"

Clarke Courier · 1886-03-25 (publication)

Locator: Page 1, column 4, "An Old Acquaintance", the reprimand

Relevant passage
a green sentry would not let them pass and was sharply reprimanded by Captain Gibbs, who told him that men wearing red ribbons on their coat lapel should pass unmolested.

Checked: Original inspected. A digital reproduction was inspected; no original has been handled.

Open source

Source family: clarke-courier-1886-old-acquaintance. Multiple passages from one source are not independent witnesses.

Reporting

Evidence role: supports. The red flannel and the escape.

Clarke Courier (Berryville, Va.), March 25, 1886, page 1: "An Old Acquaintance"

Clarke Courier · 1886-03-25 (publication)

Locator: Page 1, column 4, "An Old Acquaintance", the red flannel

Relevant passage
He had some red flannel in the inside of his vest; he tore off a strip, pinned it to his coat, watched his opportunity, got past the guard, and reached the Union lines in safety.

Checked: Original inspected. A digital reproduction was inspected; no original has been handled.

Open source

Source family: clarke-courier-1886-old-acquaintance. Multiple passages from one source are not independent witnesses.

AI-assisted source check (Claude Opus 5) · 2026-09-24. How this project checks its sources

The Richmond Dispatch of November 6, 1861 described prisoners of war as consigned to the care of “Capt. Gibbs, the energetic officer commanding at the military prisons.”

✓ Supported by a source
See the source and its limits
✓ Supported by a sourceAn account exists

The Richmond Dispatch of November 6, 1861 described prisoners of war as consigned to the care of “Capt. Gibbs, the energetic officer commanding at the military prisons.”

What the source supports

That an officer named Gibbs commanded the Richmond military prisons in late 1861.

Uncertainty

Read as a transcription on civilwarrichmond.com, not the newspaper page. The item gives no first name or initial, so it does not by itself establish which Gibbs this was.

Source

Reporting

Evidence role: supports. Gibbs commanding the military prisons, 1861.

Richmond Dispatch, November 6, 1861, page 2: "Arrival." (transcription)

Richmond Dispatch · 1861-11-06 (publication)

Locator: Page 2, column 5, "Arrival."

Relevant passage
Two prisoners of war reached this city yesterday afternoon by the Central train, and were consigned to the care of Capt. Gibbs, the energetic officer commanding at the military prisons.

Checked: Page text reviewed. Original image not independently inspected.

Open source

Source family: richmond-dispatch-prisons-1861-1862. Multiple passages from one source are not independent witnesses.

AI-assisted source check (Claude Opus 5) · 2026-09-24. How this project checks its sources

The Richmond Dispatch of January 13, 1862 reported that Captain Gibbs, who had had charge of the prison depots in Richmond, had been promoted to Major in the Provisional Army and was going to Salisbury, North Carolina, that morning, and that the Richmond prisons would be kept as a receiving depot under Lieut. Hairston of the 19th Mississippi regiment.

✓ Supported by a source
See the source and its limits
✓ Supported by a sourceAn account exists

The Richmond Dispatch of January 13, 1862 reported that Captain Gibbs, who had had charge of the prison depots in Richmond, had been promoted to Major in the Provisional Army and was going to Salisbury, North Carolina, that morning, and that the Richmond prisons would be kept as a receiving depot under Lieut. Hairston of the 19th Mississippi regiment.

What the source supports

That the Gibbs who had charge of the Richmond prisons left the city in January 1862.

Uncertainty

Read as a transcription on civilwarrichmond.com, not the newspaper page. It reports a departure, not a permanent absence, and says nothing about where this officer served later.

Source

Reporting

Evidence role: supports. Gibbs promoted and leaving Richmond, January 1862.

Richmond Dispatch, January 13, 1862, page 2: "The Government Prisons" (transcription)

Richmond Dispatch · 1862-01-13 (publication)

Locator: Page 2, column 3, "The Government Prisons"

Relevant passage
Captain Gibbs, who for some time past has had charge of the prison depots here, has been promoted to the rank of Major in the Provisional Army, and goes to Salisbury, N. C., this morning, to which place all the prisoners not sent away under flag of truce will be transferred. The prisons in Richmond will be kept as a receiving depot, and placed in charge of Lieut. Hairston, of the 19th Mississippi regiment.

Checked: Page text reviewed. Original image not independently inspected.

Open source

Source family: richmond-dispatch-prisons-1861-1862. Multiple passages from one source are not independent witnesses.

AI-assisted source check (Claude Opus 5) · 2026-09-24. How this project checks its sources

A 1980 master’s thesis on the Richmond prisons states that early in March 1862 prisoners were moved from the tobacco warehouses of Rocketts into the four-storey building owned by Libby and Sons, and that Lieutenant Thomas P. Turner assumed command of the prison.

✓ Supported by a source
See the source and its limits
✓ Supported by a sourceAn account exists

A 1980 master’s thesis on the Richmond prisons states that early in March 1862 prisoners were moved from the tobacco warehouses of Rocketts into the four-storey building owned by Libby and Sons, and that Lieutenant Thomas P. Turner assumed command of the prison.

What the source supports

When the building became a prison, and who commanded it.

Uncertainty

Secondary scholarship of 1980, cited for a background date. The underlying records it rests on were not examined for this page.

Source

Later historical account

Evidence role: supports. When the Libby building became a prison.

Daniel W. Robinson, "Belle Isle: Prison in the James, 1862-1865" (M.A. thesis, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, 1980), page 25

Daniel W. Robinson · 1980-08 (publication)

Locator: Page 25, the move to the Libby and Sons building

Relevant passage
Early in March, 1862, authorities in Richmond shifted prisoners from the tobacco warehouses of Rocketts to a large four-story building owned by Libby and Sons. … Lieutenant Thomas P. Turner assumed command of the prison.

Checked: Page text reviewed. Original image not independently inspected.

Open source

Source family: robinson-belle-isle-1980. Multiple passages from one source are not independent witnesses.

AI-assisted source check (Claude Opus 5) · 2026-09-24. How this project checks its sources

The Clarke Courier itself printed, twice in 1871, that Captain George W. Alexander had commanded at Castle Thunder in Richmond during the war.

✓ Supported by a source
See the source and its limits
✓ Supported by a sourceAn account exists

The Clarke Courier itself printed, twice in 1871, that Captain George W. Alexander had commanded at Castle Thunder in Richmond during the war.

What the source supports

Who the Courier’s readers had been told commanded the other Richmond prison.

Uncertainty

Read as the Chronicling America text layer only, and both blocks are visibly garbled by OCR; no page image was inspected for either issue. Both items are the Courier relaying other papers. That Alexander commanded Castle Thunder does not by itself exclude an officer named Gibbs from either prison.

Source

Reporting

Evidence role: supports. Alexander at Castle Thunder, April 1871.

Clarke Courier (Berryville, Va.), April 6, 1871, page 4: "The Commandant at Castle Thunder"

Clarke Courier · 1871-04-06 (publication)

Locator: Page 4, column 2, "The Commandant at Castle Thunder"

Relevant passage
Captain Geo’ge W. Alexander, commandant at the famous “Castle Thunder” duiing the war

Checked: Existing OCR reviewed. Original image not independently inspected.

Open source

Source family: clarke-courier-castle-thunder-1871. Multiple passages from one source are not independent witnesses.

Reporting

Evidence role: supports. The same, July 1871.

Clarke Courier (Berryville, Va.), July 27, 1871, page 2: news paragraphs

Clarke Courier · 1871-07-27 (publication)

Locator: Page 2, column 4, news paragraphs

Relevant passage
Captain G. W. Alexander, who commanded at Castle Thunder, Richmond, Va., during the war, has been appointed business manager and general superintendent of the Memphis Appeal Company.

Checked: Existing OCR reviewed. Original image not independently inspected.

Open source

Source family: clarke-courier-castle-thunder-1871. Multiple passages from one source are not independent witnesses.

AI-assisted source check (Claude Opus 5) · 2026-09-24. How this project checks its sources

Also indexed as: the Richmond military prisons.

Know something about this place or record? Help fill a gap. It stays private until it is reviewed.

Keep exploring

Related stories

Service & war? Unconfirmed

A reported reunion after Libby Prison

In March 1886 the Clarke Courier printed a small scene under the heading “An Old Acquaintance”: an old man in a hotel, a stranger off a train, and an unpaid board bill that turns out to be an escape from Libby Prison. It is a good story, and parts of it do not sit easily with the records.

What the evidence says Six sources. The 1886 Clarke Courier item that carries the whole anecdote was read on the page image. The other five bear only on whether its names and dates fit the record. No prison roster or muster record was consulted.

  • 3 min read
  • 6 sources

Search

Searches the released collection only.